WEALTH TIP OF THE MONTH

 The Tangible Property Regulations: History, Requirements, and Compliance Strategies  

​

Introduction
 

The Tangible Property Regulations (TPRs), also known as the "repair regulations," represent one of the most significant tax code overhauls in decades. These regulations fundamentally changed how businesses must account for costs associated with acquiring, producing, improving, repairing, and maintaining tangible property. For business owners and their financial advisors, understanding these regulations is not optional—they establish mandatory guidelines with substantial financial implications and potential penalties for non-compliance. 
 

Historical Development 

The journey toward the final TPRs began in 2004 when the IRS first proposed regulations addressing the treatment of costs related to tangible property. These initial proposals aimed to clarify the often-blurry line between capital improvements (which must be depreciated over time) and repairs and maintenance expenses (which can be immediately deducted). 
 

After several iterations and extensive feedback from tax professionals, the IRS issued temporary regulations in December 2011, followed by final regulations (T.D. 9636) on September 19, 2013. These regulations became effective for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2014, giving taxpayers time to implement the necessary systems and procedures for compliance. 
 

In 2014, the IRS further refined the regulations by issuing Rev. Proc. 2014-16, which provided guidance on how to implement the necessary accounting method changes to comply with the new rules. Additional clarifications came through Rev. Proc. 2015-20, which offered simplified procedures for small businesses. 
 

Key Provisions

​

The TPRs provide comprehensive guidance across several critical areas: 

1. Materials and Supplies: The regulations distinguish between incidental materials and supplies (immediately deductible when purchased) and non-incidental materials and supplies (deductible when used or consumed). 

2. De Minimis Safe Harbor: This allows businesses to deduct rather than capitalize certain amounts paid for tangible property based on thresholds established by their accounting procedures. For businesses with applicable financial statements, the threshold is $5,000 per item or invoice, while those without such statements have a $2,500 threshold. 

3. Routine Maintenance Safe Harbor: Expenses for routine maintenance activities expected to be performed more than once during an asset's class life can be expensed rather than capitalized. 

4. Building Improvement Rules: The regulations establish criteria for determining whether expenditures for building improvements must be capitalized. These focus on improvements to building systems (HVAC, plumbing, electrical) and building structures. 

5. Unit of Property Definition: The regulations define what constitutes a unit of property, which is crucial for determining whether an expenditure is a repair or an improvement. 

6. Disposition Rules: These provide guidelines for recognizing gain or loss when disposing of a portion of property. 

​

Compliance Requirements 

​

The TPRs require businesses to take several specific actions to ensure compliance: 

1. Capitalization Policies:  Businesses must establish written capitalization policies that align with the regulations. 

2. General Asset Accounts (GAAs):  Companies may need to establish GAAs to properly track and account for asset dispositions. 

3. Method Changes:  Most businesses needed to file Form 3115 (Application for Change in Accounting Method) to align their accounting practices with the regulations. 

4. Annual Elections:  Certain provisions, such as the de minimis safe harbor, require annual elections on timely filed tax returns. 

5. Documentation Systems:  Businesses must maintain adequate documentation to support their treatment of expenditures under the regulations. 

​​

Penalties for Non-Compliance 

​

Failure to comply with the TPRs can result in significant penalties and adverse tax consequences: 

1. Accuracy-Related Penalties: The IRS can impose penalties of 20% of the underpayment amount resulting from improper treatment of expenses under IRC §6662. 

2. Interest Charges: Underpayments resulting from non-compliance accrue interest until paid. 

3. Extended Statute of Limitations: Substantial omissions of income can extend the statute of limitations from three to six years. 

4. Method Change Complications: Failing to properly implement required accounting method changes can create complexities in future tax filings and potentially trigger IRS scrutiny. 

5. Loss of Deductions: Without proper documentation and compliance, businesses risk having deductible repair expenses reclassified as capital improvements, delaying tax benefits over many years. 

 

The penalty for substantial understatement of income tax equals 20% of the underpayment if the understatement exceeds the greater of 10% of the tax required or $5,000 for individuals ($10,000 for corporations). This makes compliance not just a regulatory requirement but a significant financial consideration. 

​

Compliance Strategies and Solutions 

 

Businesses can implement several strategies to ensure compliance with the TPRs while maximizing available tax benefits: 

1. Conduct a Fixed Asset Review: A comprehensive review of your fixed asset tax schedules can identify opportunities for partial dispositions, expense versus capitalization analysis, and potential look-back adjustments that may provide large immediate tax deductions. 

2. Implement Robust Capitalization Policies: Establish clear written policies that incorporate the de minimis safe harbor and define what constitutes routine maintenance based on your industry and assets. 

3. Develop Documentation Systems: Create systems to document repair and maintenance activities, including photographs, work orders, and expense categorization that clearly distinguish between repairs and improvements. 

4. Cost Segregation Studies: These studies can identify components of building projects that qualify for shorter recovery periods or immediate expensing, particularly useful with the expanded bonus depreciation provisions. 

5. Annual Election Management: Implement procedures to ensure required annual elections, such as the de minimis safe harbor election, are properly made on timely filed returns. 

6. Staff Training: Ensure accounting and facilities personnel understand the distinction between capital improvements and repairs to properly code expenses at the time of transaction. 

7. Regular Compliance Reviews: Conduct periodic reviews to ensure ongoing compliance and to identify any necessary accounting method changes. 

 

Conclusion 

​

The Tangible Property Regulations represent a complex but unavoidable aspect of tax compliance for businesses with tangible assets. While they initially created significant implementation challenges, they also provide opportunities for tax savings through proper planning and documentation. 

 

The key to successful compliance lies in understanding the regulations' nuances and establishing systems that integrate compliance requirements into everyday business operations. By working with knowledgeable tax professionals to implement these regulations properly, businesses can not only avoid penalties but potentially realize significant tax benefits through optimized treatment of expenditures related to their tangible property. 

​

For business owners and their advisors, the TPRs underscore the importance of proactive tax planning rather than reactive tax reporting. In an era of increased IRS scrutiny of business returns, compliance with these regulations provides not just peace of mind but tangible financial benefits through properly structured and documented property-related expenditures. 

​

If you would like to learn more about the tangible property regulations and how you might benefit from them, please contact me at? 

​

barry.boscoe@brightonadvisory.com 

Office: 818-342-9950 

   Mobile: 818-802-0686